Department of Justice

Tasmanian Industrial Commission

www.tas.gov.au
Contact  |  Accessibility  |  Disclaimer

T5535 T5536 T5537 T5538 T5490 T5495 - 23 June 1995

 

TASMANIAN INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION

Industrial Relations Act 1984
s.23 application for award or variation of award

Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited
(T.5535 of 1995)
(T.5536 of 1995)
(T.5537 of 1995)
(T.5538 of 1995)

Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union
(T.5509 of 1995)
(T.5490 of 1995)

Minister for Industrial Relations and Training
(T.5495 of 1995)

AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRIES AWARD
CLERICAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE EMPLOYEES (PRIVATE SECTOR) AWARD
MISCELLANEOUS WORKERS AWARD
NATIONAL TRAINING WAGE AWARD
NATIONAL TRAINING WAGE (TASMANIAN PRIVATE SECTOR) AWARD
RETAIL TRADES AWARD
TRANSPORT WORKERS GENERAL AWARD

 

FULL BENCH
DEPUTY PRESIDENT A ROBINSON
COMMISSIONER R J WATLING
COMMISSIONER R K GOZZI

HOBART, 23 JUNE 1995

New Award - National Training Wage - including industries of certain awards within the jurisdiction of the Commission - application granted - operative ffpp 16.6.95

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Commission received a total of seven applications which sought to make special provision in various private sector awards for a national training wage as contemplated by the Commonwealth Government's White Paper on Jobs Growth entitled "Working Nation".

There was initially a diversity of approaches adopted by the various parties in seeking the best method of giving effect to the desired outcome. The Minister for Industrial Relations and Training sought in application T No 5495 to vary the Retail Trades Award; the Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union sought in application T No 5490 of 1995 to vary the Automotive Industries Award, and by separate application in T No 5509 of 1995 to create a new National Training Wage Award having as its scope the industry covered by the Automotive Industries Award; the Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Ltd (TCCI) sought in application T No 5538 to create a new National Training Wage (Tasmanian Private Sector) Award which would be applicable to industries falling within the scope clause of a significant number of nominated existing awards; TCCI also sought in application T No 5535, T No 5536 and T No 5537 of 1995 to vary the Administrative and Clerical Employees Award, the Miscellaneous Workers Award, and the Transport Workers General Awards respectively to link them with the proposed National Training Wage (Tasmanian Private Sector) Award.

There also existed a situation where some organisations of employees opposed the notion of a training wage being made the subject of award prescription whereas others agreed.

The Commission sought to facilitate the resolution of the differences which existed between the parties by firstly directing them into conferences and then conferring privately with a representative group.

In the result it was agreed that the number of applications being actively pursued be reduced in number to four (4) for practical reasons, being TCCI applications T.5538, T.5535, T.5536 and T.5537 of 1995. It also became apparent that the schedule of awards listed in application T.5538 of 1995 could be divided into two groups, i.e. those where there was agreement to their inclusion (or no opposition had been expressed in this regard) and those whose inclusion was opposed.

Having identified the issues we then heard argument concerning the question of merit of the proposals before us concerning a national training wage and associated provisions. In this regard we were provided with a number of exhibits which included the following:

(a) The National Training Wage Interim Award 1994 Decision1 made by a Full Bench of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission on 12 September 1994.

(b) A Commonwealth Employment Services booklet titled "Build Your Business With New Employment Training Opportunities".

(c) Reasons for Decision issued by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission on 7 February 1995 in relation to the filing of two industrial agreements pursuant to Section 55 of the Act. Both were in respect of "National Training Wage Agreements" in the public sector.

We also heard submissions from those who supported the concept of award provisions as proposed as well as from those who opposed the idea.

Decision

We now confirm our decision which was announced at the conclusion of proceedings on Friday 16 June 1995.

We advise that we have had regard for all of the evidence and material placed before us and the submissions made which went to the advantages of making a new award to be known as the National Training Wage (Tasmanian Private Sector) Award in the terms of application T No 5538 of 1995.

Similarly we have given consideration to the correspondence received and the submissions made by other organisations who either expressed an objection to the inclusion of certain industries covered by awards in which they have a registered interest, or who still held reservations in this regard.

Having weighed the competing positions we have decided that the principal proposal before us contained in application T.5538 of 1995 has merit and is consistent with the Commission's Wage Fixing Principle2 and public interest.

Accordingly we have decided to make a new award in the terms of TCCI application T No 5538 of 1995, as amended. Such award will initially extend only to those industries falling within the scope of awards listed in revised schedule "A" which is appended to our decision.

The question as to the possible inclusion of other awards which were the subject of objection will be considered by us at a further hearing which will be held at Hobart commencing at 10.30am on Friday 7 July 1995. At that hearing we will need to be advised if previous objections are still held or if there is consent to extend the application of the new award as originally proposed. Objecting organisations will be heard in relation to all of the awards in which they have a registered interest, which should be listed. We understand that the TTLC will assist by co-ordinating the response of affiliate organisations in this regard.

As previously expressed on 16 June 1995 we have also decided for the same reasons to amend three occupational awards namely the:

  • the Clerical and Administrative Employees (Private Sector) Award

  • the Miscellaneous Workers Award, and

  • the Transport Workers General Award

Those awards were the subject of TCCI applications in matters T No 5535, T No 5536 and T No 5537 of 1995.

Those awards will be amended to include a provision relating to the application of the National Training Wage (Private Sector) to employees covered by those awards.

Operative Date

The date of effect of those matters actually decided will be the first full pay period to commence on or after 16 June 1995.

Orders are attached.

 

Appearances:
Mr K O'Brien with Mr D O'Byrne for the Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union - Tasmanian Branch
Mr P Baker for the Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union
Mr C Brown for the Health Services Union of Australia, Tasmania No 1 Branch
Mr G Cooper for The AWU-FIME Amalgamated Union, Tasmania Branch, the National Union of Workers, Tasmanian Branch, the Textile, Clothing and Footwear Union of Australia, Tasmanian Branch and The Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union, Tasmanian Branch
Mr M Cordwell and Mr J Gill for the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, Tasmanian Branch
Mr P Noonan for the Shop Distributive and Allied Employees Association, Tasmanian Branch
Mrs H Dowd for the Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union
Mr R Warwick for the Tasmanian Trades and Labor Council
Mr R Joyce for the Tasmanian Automobile Chamber of Commerce
Mr D McDougall for the Tasmanian Chamber of Retailers
Mr S Knott for the Australian Mines and Metals Association (Incorporated) and on behalf of Emu Bay Railway Company Limited and Pasminco Metals - Rosebery (West Coast Mines)
Mr M Flynn for the Meat and Allied Trades' Federation of Australia (Tasmanian Division)
Mr T Edwards with Mr M Watson and Mr B Murray for the Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited on behalf of the Tasmanian Farmers and Graziers Employers Association, the Tasmanian Sawmillers Industrial Association, the Hop Producers' Association of Tasmania, the Metal Industries Association Tasmania, Pasminco Metals - EZ (Risdon), Goliath Portland Cement Company Limited, Railton, the Retail Traders Association of Tasmania, the Pharmacy Guild of Australia, the Master Builders Association, the Printing and Allied Trades Employers' Federation of Australia and the Community Services Employer Organisation (Tasmania)
Mr T Pearce intervening for the Minister for Industrial Relations and Training

Date and Place of Hearing:
1995.
Hobart:
June 16

SCHEDULE A

Aerated Waters Award
Architects (Private Industry) Award
Automotive Industries
AwardBakers Award
Barristers and Solicitors Award
Broadcasting and Television Award
Carriers Award
Catholic Education Award
Community Services Award
Dentists Award
Draughting and Technical Officers (Private Industry) Award
Electrical Engineers Award
Emu Bay Railway Award
Entertainment Award
Estate Agents Award
Hairdressers Award
Health and Fitness Centres Award
Hospitals Award
Hotels, Resorts, Hospitality & Motels Award
Ice Cream Makers Award
Independent Schools (Non-Teaching Staff) Award
Laundry and Dry Cleaning Award
Leather, Canvas and Sheet Plastic Fabrication Award
Licensed Clubs Award
Marine Boards Award
Medical Diagnostic Services (Private Sector) Award
Medical Practitioners (Private Sector) Award
Metal and Engineering On-Site Construction Industry Award
Musicians Award
Nursing Homes Award
Printers Award
Public Accountants Award
Public Vehicles Award
Restaurant Keepers Award
Retail Trades Award
Shipbuilders Award
Shipping Award
Surveyors (Private Industry) Award
Timber Merchants Award
Totalizator Agency Award
Vegetable Preservers Award
Veterinary Services Award
Welfare and Voluntary Agencies Award
Wholesale Plant Bakeries Award

1 Print L5188
2 T.5214 of 1994