Department of Justice

Tasmanian Industrial Commission

www.tas.gov.au
Contact  |  Accessibility  |  Disclaimer

T3969

 

TASMANIAN INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION

Industrial Relations Act 1984
s23 application for award or variation of award

Minister Administering the Tasmanian State Service Act 1982
(T3969 of 1992)

FIRE BRIGADES AWARD

 

DEPUTY PRESIDENT A ROBINSON

HOBART, 14 September 1992

Award variation - application to vary Fire Brigades Award - applicant requested application be joined with part-heard matter T2594 of 1992 - request denied

REASONS FOR DECISION

The abovementioned application was lodged by the Minister administering the Tasmanian State Act 1984 on 28 August 1992 and has now been assigned to me for hearing and determination pursuant to Section 15(1)(a) of the Act.

Before such assignment occurred the parties involved in matter T2594, being a claim by the United Firefighters Union of Tasmania (UFU) for new career paths and salary structures to be inserted in the Fire Brigades Award which is substantially part heard, debated whether or not this recent application by the Minister should be joined to application T2594 of 1990 and sought a ruling from me.

The particulars of the Minister's recent application state that, inter alia, it is to "vary the Fire Brigades Award in accordance with decision T2399 of 1990 and T2954 of 1990". I am rather perplexed in this regard because application T2399 of 1990 is an application by the Tasmanian Public Service Association to vary a comprehensive list of nominated public sector awards but application T2594 of 1990 is an application by the UFU for a new career structure for certain of its members only.

And, whereas the first mentioned matter (and others) are still before the Public Sector Full Bench, T2594 of 1990, which certainly was originally before the public sector Full Bench, was subsequently assigned to me for hearing and determination on 4 December 1991.

I also note that in its "Further Interim Decision" of 29 November 1991 the public sector Full Bench stated at page 3 that, inter alia:

"Since our last decision in these matters on 1 July 1991, the issues raised therein have been comprehensively canvassed and addressed by the parties. This has involved extensive submissions and arguments during which the unions and the Minister administering the Tasmanian State Service Act (the Minister) have outlined their respective positions on proposals designed to accommodate new classification structures in four new occupational streams, viz. Operational, Clerical, Professional and Technical.

The other streams are being, or are to be dealt with in a different manner.

For example, the teaching service stream is being considered by a different Full Bench and the four awards which make up the Emergency and Custodial Services Stream, viz. the Ambulance Service Award, the Fire Brigades Award, the Police Award and the Prison Officers Award, will be referred individually to the Commission members dealing with those award areas."

Accordingly I can find no support either in the above quote or in any of the series of decisions of the public sector Full Bench for the notion that I should join recent application T3969 of 1992 to the already substantially part-heard application of the UFU.

Whilst I can appreciate and accept that the Wage Fixation Principles of this Commission must be considered as a whole before deciding any industrial claims the Act gives to the Commission the right to regulate its own procedure and so far as I am concerned this depends very much on the circumstances of each case.

Obviously there has been more than ample opportunity for the Minister and the UFU to negotiate a package incorporating both wage rates and conditions of employment at the enterprise level if that was desired, but now that the only avenue of resolution is arbitration I am not prepared to consider a plethora of items which have been submitted at this late stage until after matter T2594 of 1990 is concluded and a decision issued.

Having ruled upon this question matter T2594 of 1990 may be relisted for an early resumption.

The parties are to confer and advise the Commission of dates which suit.

 

A Robinson
DEPUTY PRESIDENT

Appearances:
Mr F Ogle with Mrs W Burgess for the Minister administering the Tasmanian State Service Act 1984.
Mr N Devine with Mr Ositis for the United Firefighters Union of Tasmania.

Date and place of hearing:
1992
August 31
Hobart