Tasmanian Government Logo
\'\'
\'Feature
 
Link to the Tas government site

Appeals

T14601 of 2018 - Appeal against a decision - Meehan v Minister administering the State Service Act 2000  (pdf, 543.7 KB)
Full Bench - 22 January 2019 - Appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President Ellis on 24 May 2018 – T14576 of 2018 – jurisdiction – competency of appeal – threshold issue – decision did not contain an order – principles in 'Bennett' apply – decision incapable of appeal – no appeal lies

T14621 of 2018 - Appeal against a decision - Assiri v Minister administering the State Service Act 200 (pdf, 680.5 KB)0
Full Bench - 22 January 2019 - Appeal against a decision handed down by President Barclay on 28 September 2018 – T14449 of 2016 – jurisdiction – competency of appeal – threshold issue – decision did not contain an order – principles in 'Bennett' apply – decision incapable of appeal – no appeal lies

T14582 of 2018 Appeal against a decision - Dudley v Minister administering the State service Act 2000-Tasmanian Health Service (pdf, 1.3 MB)
Full Bench - 29 November 2018 - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Gay on 2 February 2018 – T14448 of 2016 – jurisdiction – competency of appeal – threshold issue – decision did not contain an order – principles in “Bennett” apply – decision incapable of appeal – no appeal lies

T14478 of 2017 - 26 April 2017 (docx, 45.3 KB)
Full Bench - President DJ Barclay, Deputy President NM Wells and Commissioner N Wilson -  - Kols Cleaning Services v Brown
Appeal against a decision handed down by a Commissioner on 30 January 2017 – T14424 of 2016 – jurisdiction – Long Service Leave Act s.14 - competency of appeal – threshold issue – absence of regulations prescribing manner of instituting, hearing and determining appeal – decision incapable of appeal – no appeal lies

T14429 (docx, 94.1 KB) - 15 November 2016
Full Bench - Commissioner MA Gay, Commissioner T Lee and Commissioner N Wilson - - Appeal against a decision handed down by Acting President Wells on 18 July 2016 – T14390 of 2016  (doc, 71.0 KB)– jurisdiction – competency of appeal – threshold issue – decision did not contain an order – decision incapable of appeal – no appeal lies

T14400 - 26 May 2016 (docx, 76.9 KB)
Full Bench - Acting  President NM Wells, Commissioner T Lee and Commissioner N Wilson -
Appeal against a decision handed down by President Abey on 18/2/16 – T14368 of 2015 – jurisdiction – competency of appeal – threshold issue – decision did not contain an order – decision incapable of appeal – no appeal lies

T14386 - 10 Feb 2016
Full Bench - Deputy President NM Wells, Commissioner T Lee and Commissioner N Wilson - Appeal against a decision of President TJ Abey in matter T14358 of 2015 (Suspension application) - Application for suspension - grounds of appeal - consent position - suspension granted

T14233 - 20 October 2014
s70 appeal by Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 against a decision handed down by President Abey in matter T14123 of 2013 – termination of employment dispute – binding agreement – binding settlement – extinguished cause of action – appeal upheld – decision and order revoked

T14194 - 11 July 2014
s14 LSL Act 1976 - Full Bench - Deputy President NM Wells, Commissioner B Deegan and Commissioner T Lee
s70 appeal by RJ and L Terry Pty Ltd against a decision handed down by President Abey on 22/01/14 – T14109 of 2013 – order issued

T14184 - 30 June 2014
Full Bench - Deputy President NM Wells, Commissioner MA Gay and Commissioner T Lee s70 appeal by United Voice, Tasmanian Branch against an order issued by President Abey on 31/1/14 – T14114 of 2013 – valid reason for termination found – double penalty – double jeopardy – procedural fairness – right to be heard – appeal dismissed

T14194 - 11 June 2014
Full Bench - Deputy President NM Wells, Commissioner B Deegan and Commissioner T Lee
s14 LSL Act 1976 - appeal by RJ and L Terry Pty Ltd  against a decision handed down by President Abey on 22/01/14 – T14109 of 2013 –record of complaint – insufficient weight - gave weight to an irrelevant matter – whether payment capable of being offset against statutory entitlements – purpose of payment- submissions sought – directions issued on 6 June 2014 - directions issued on 13 March 2014

T14214 - 12 May 2014
Full Bench - Deputy President NM Wells, Commissioner B Deegan and Commissioner MA Gay
s70 appeal by Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 against a decision handed down by President Abey in matter T14097 of 2013 - Australian Nursing Federation, Tasmanian Branch v Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 - industrial dispute – child and family health home visitor nurses – classification review – principles for award construction – mutuality of intention – applicant entitled to be heard on the merits - classification descriptors – application of descriptors - best fit
s71(4) application by Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 for suspension of the operation of decision pending the determination of the appeal – consent position – decision  granting suspension issued

T14056 - 13 August 2013
Full Bench - President TJ Abey, Commissioner B Deegan and Commissioner MA Gay
s70 appeal by Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 against a decision handed down by Deputy President Wells on 11/04/13 – T13954 of 2012 – translation process – classification resolution process - classification descriptors – statement of duties – role of Commission in determining classification disputes - ‘best fit’ – appeal dismissed - order issued

T14002 - 21 June 2013
Full Bench - Acting President N Wells, Commissioner B Deegan and Commissioner MA Gay
s70 appeal  - Australian Nursing Federation, Tasmanian Branch - appeal against a decision handed down by President Abey on 13/11/12 – T13915 of 2012 – competency of appeal – threshold issue – meaning of “order” - procedural fairness – natural justice – power to amend or vary - principle of functus officio – President amended his decision - exercise statutory function – President was functus officio when he issued amendment – decision did not contain an order – decision incapable of appeal – no appeal lies

T14056 - 27 May 2013
Full Bench - President TJ Abey, Commissioner B Deegan and Commissioner MA Gay
s70 appeal  - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Health Services Union of Australia, Tasmania No. 1 Branch - application for suspension made pursuant to Section 71(4) of the Industrial Relations Act 1984 by Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 – grounds of appeal – further and better particulars - whether lodged out of time - arguable case – balance of convenience – suspension granted – directions issued

T13901 - 8 August 2012
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President TJ Abey and Commissioner B Deegan
s70 appeal - J K Peddell and S E Peddell trading as Bing-I-Oysters - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J McAlpine on 11/4/12 – T13833 of 2011 – appeal upheld decision of Commissioner revoked

T13898 - 8 August 2012
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner MA Gay and Commissioner B Deegan
s70 appeal - Police Association of Tasmania - appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President T J Abey arising out of T13844 of 2011 - Appeal dismissed by majority decision – Decision confirmed

T13812 - 14 September 2011
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President Tim Abey and Commissioner B Deegan
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Margaret Howell - Appeal against a decision of Deputy President Abey in Matter T13775 of 2011 - Directions

T13776 and T13778 - 15 September 2011
President PL Leary
s70 appeals - Jagat Singh Rana (T13778 of 2011) and Anil & Manju Sharma t/a Magic Curries (T13776 of 2011) - Appeals against a decision of Commissioner McAlpine in Matters No. T13609 and T13610 of 2009 - Terms of Settlement

T13750 - 25 May 2011
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner JP McAlpine and Commissioner B Deegan
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Warwick Alan Butler - Appeal against a decision of Deputy President Abey in Matter T13712 of 2010 - Amended Directions

T13750 - 19 May 2011
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner JP McAlpine and Commissioner B Deegan
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Warwick Alan Butler - Appeal against a decision of Deputy President Abey in Matter T13712 of 2010 - Directions

T13586 - 4 February 2011
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President Tim Abey and  Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Australian Nursing Federation Tasmanian Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President P C Shelley arising out of T12671 of 2006 shift workers and public holidays - admissibility of new material - principles of construction - appeal upheld and orders revoked - election to take time off in lieu - the Deputy President made no finding but suggested parties confer - no ground for appeal

T13678 - 12 January 2011
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner JP McAlpine and  Commissioner M Gay
s70 appeal - The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Tasmania) Inc. and Greg Tredinnick - appeal against an order issued in T13631 of 2009 (DP Abey) - appeal upheld - order revoked in part - new order issued.

T13678 - 28 July 2010
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner JP McAlpine and Commissioner B Deegan
s71(4) application to suspend - The Royal Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Tasmania) Inc and Greg Tredinnick - Application to suspend operation of a decision - application granted

T13644 - 22 November 2010
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President TJ Abey and  Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Glenn E Gibson - Appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President P C Shelley arising out of T13435 of 2009 - Appeal upheld by majority decision - Decision revoked - DECISION SUBJECT TO SUPREME COURT PROCEEDINGS. In a judgment issued on 2 October 2013 Blow CJ dismissed the application. The Full Bench decision in T13644 did not dispose of T13435, which therefore remained extant. In Matter T14113 of 2013 the parties agreed that the appropriate way forward was to reconstitute the Full Bench in T13644 in order to dispose of the matter - This process could be by either a single Commissioner (s71(13)(c)) or the Full Bench (s71(13)(b)) - The parties further agreed that there was no barrier to President Abey being a member of the bench, notwithstanding that he was a (dissenting) member of the previous Full Bench - The President, pursuant to s15(f) of the IR Act has determined that the reconstituted Full Bench in T13644 will be Abey P, Wells DP and Deegan C. - The reconstituted Full Bench determines that it will consider the merits of T13435 as a Full Bench pursuant to s71(13)(b) - The matter will be considered and determined on the material before Deputy President Shelley and it is unlikely that there will be a need for further hearing - d etermination of the merits of original application T13435 of 2009 as decision was revoked by the Full Bench without it determining the merits of the matter - process – classification descriptors – band 6 – band 7 – “best fit” – decision issued determining the merits of the matter - order issued on 23 May 2014 assigning the classification of band 7 to the position

T13586 - 29 July 2010
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President TJ Abey and  Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Australian Nursing Federation Tasmanian Branch - Amended Directions

T13586 - 27 July 2010
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President TJ Abey and  Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Australian Nursing Federation Tasmanian Branch - Directions

T13586 - 22 March 2010
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President TJ Abey and  Commissioner JP McAlpine
s71(4) application to suspend - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and Australian Nursing Federation Tasmanian Branch - Application to suspend orders handed down by Deputy President P C Shelley arising out of T12671 of 2006 - consent order issued

T13485 - 26 August 2010
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President TJ Abey and  Commissioner M Gay
s70 appeal - Dr Stephen Bennett and Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J P McAlpine arising out of T12723 of 2006 issued 29 July 2009 – Appeal dismissed

T13485 - 4 January 2010
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70 appeal - Dr Stephen Bennett and Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 - Directions

T13504 - 5 October 2009
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy Commissioner TJ Abey and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Darko Krajinovic and Debbie Maree Pouwelse - Appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President P C Shelley arising out of T13369 of 2009 Appeal upheld Order of the Deputy President quashed

T13202 - 7 January 2009
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and The Community and Public Sector Union (State Public Services Federation Tasmania) Inc - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T13150 of 2008 Appeal upheld Decision revoked

T13176 - 7 April 2009
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and United Firefighters Union of Tasmania - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T13022 of 2007 - Appeal Grounds 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6(b) rejected Grounds 4 and 6(a) upheld - decision revoked - T13022 of 2007 referred back to Commissioner Abey

T13167 - 17 December 2008
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70 appeal - Dr Stephen Bennett and Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner McAlpine arising out of T12919 of 2007 alleged unfair termination - jurisdiction - whether an appeal lies against a decision to dismiss an application - found that decision was an action pursuant to s31 of the Act appeal lies

T13167 - 11 June 2008
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70 appeal - Dr Stephen Bennett and Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 - Directions

T13037 - 24 January 2008
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70 appeal - Skilled Group Limited and Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, Tasmanian Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J P McAlpine arising out of T12999 of 2007 - Appeal rejected - T12999 of 2007 referred back to Commissioner McAlpine

T12891 - 8 November 2007
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - D G Lewis Pty Ltd and Health Services Union of Australia, Tasmania No 1 Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner TJ Abey arising out of T12613 of 2006 - Appeal dismissed - original decision and order confirmed

T12855 - 26 March 2007
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70 appeal - Dr Stephen Bennett and Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J P McAlpine arising out of T12723 of 2006 - new evidence pursuant to s.71(8) - decision revoked - T12723 of 2006 referred back to Commissioner J P McAlpine for rehearing

T12822 - 2 May 2007
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner TJ Abey, Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Crossroads Civil Contracting Pty Ltd and Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, Tasmanian Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President Shelley arising out of T12546 of 2006 - Appeal rejected - Decision and Order confirmed

T12740 and T12759 - 31 August 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70 appeal - Sphere Pty Ltd trading as Barron's Char Grill
and Douglas Joseph Peter Massey - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J P McAlpine arising out of T12672 of 2006 - Jurisdiction - Constitutional Corporation

T12696 - 4 August 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Adrian Wayne Venn and St Anne's Homes Inc - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T.J. Abey arising out of T12600 of 2006 - appeal dismissed

T12670 - 4 August 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner TJ Abey, Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City and Georgina Margaret Taylor - Appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President P.C. Shelley arising out of T12466 of 2005 - order revoked

T12658 - 30 August 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Alan Griffiths and Port of Devonport Corporation - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T.J. Abey arising out of T11272 of 2004 appeal dismissed decision upheld

T12606 - 24 October 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70(1) appeal - Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City and Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union, Tasmanian Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J P McAlpine arising out of T12431 of 2005 - Appeal dismissed - original decision and order confirmed

T12605 - 17 May 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70(1) appeal - Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City and Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union, Tasmanian Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J P McAlpine arising out of T12300 of 2005 - Appeal dismissed

T12556 - 30 October 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP Mc Alpine
s70(1) appeal - Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, Tasmanian Branch - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T12268 of 2005 - Appeal dismissed - original decision confirmed

T12424 - 16 February 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner TJ Abey, Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Timothy Roy Roland and Hobart Workers Club Inc - Appeal against a Consent Order issued by Deputy President P C Shelley arising out of T12211 of 2005 - Appeal dismissed

T12404 - 27 April 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Minister administering the State Service Act 2000 and David Arthur Shaw - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T12143 of 2005 - Appeal dismissed - original decision confirmed

T12391 - 3 January 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70(1) appeal - Barry Kingston and T & E Gadzinski (Tomas Gadzinski, Elzbieta Gadzinski) - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner J P McAlpine arising out of T12176 of 2005 - Appeal rejected - decision upheld

T12321, T12322, T12323 and T12341 - 13 June 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Zinifex Australia Limited
(T12321 of 2005) Australian Mines and Metals Association (Incorporated) (T12322 of 2005) Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union, Tasmanian Branch (T12323 of 2005) The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch (T12341 of 2005) and The TESA Group Pty Ltd and Skilled Group Limited - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T11802 and T11848 of 2004 - Order varied - UNDER APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

T12264 - 27 April 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70(1) appeal - Christine Anne Armstrong and St Luke Medical Services Pty Ltd - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner McAlpine arising out of T12011 of 2005 - Appeal rejected - Decision confirmed

T12182 - 20 March 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Australian Mines and Metals Association (Incorporated)
and The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Tim Abey arising out of T11961 of 2005

T12125 - 10 January 2006
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Tempo Services Limited and AM Services Pty Ltd and Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union, Tasmanian Branch - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner McAlpine arising out of T11893 of 2005 - Appeal rejected - Decision and Order confirmed

T12052 - 2 August 2005
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union - Tasmanian Branch and Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City -  Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T11391 of 2004

T12027 - 8 November 2005
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner TJ Abey, Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Zinifex Australia Limited and The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch - appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President Shelley arising out of T11982 of 2005 - Application by Zinifex Australia Limited pursuant to s.24(4A) of the Act

T12027 -  17 June 2005
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Commissioner TJ Abey, Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Zinifex Australia Limited and The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch - appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President Shelley arising out of T11982 of 2005 - threshold matters determined - directions to parties

T11860 Correction Order - 4 August 2005
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner TJ Abey
s70 appeal - Patchs Variety and Samantha-Jo Lewis - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner JP McAlpine arising out of T11576 of 2004 - original Order revoked - new Order issued

T11860 - 2 May 2005
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President P.C. Shelley and Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70 appeal - Patchs Variety and Samantha-Jo Lewis - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner JP McAlpine arising out of T11576 of 2004 - original Order revoked - new Order issued

T11844 - 8 April 2005
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President P.C. Shelley and Commissioner J.P. McAlpine
s70(1) appeal - Willow Court Training and Construction Pty Ltd ("Willow Court") and Sally-Anne Shade - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of matter T11683 of 2004 - appeal rejected - order confirmed

T11681 - 13 December 2004
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Commissioner T.J. Abey and Commissioner J.P. McAlpine
s70(1) s70 appeal - Peter Pinchin trading as Pete's Statewide Couriers and Paul Anthony Burridge - appeal against a decision handed down by Deputy President Shelley arising out of T11466 of 2004 - Appeal dismissed - order confirmed

T11594 - 9 December 2004
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President P.C. Shelley and Commissioner J.P. McAlpine
s70 appeal - Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union -
Tasmanian Branch and Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T11391 of 2004

T11594 - 7 December 2004
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President P.C. Shelley and Commissioner J.P. McAlpine
s70 appeal - Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union -
Tasmanian Branch and Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T11391 of 2004

T11559 and T11563 - 22 December 2004
Full Bench - President PL Leary, Deputy President PC Shelley and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City v Tennille Joanne Avadon and Tennille Joanne Avadon v Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City - Appeals against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T11275 of 2004 - Appeals rejected - order confirmed

T11445 - 21 June 2004
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President P.C. Shelley and Commissioner J.P. McAlpine
s70 appeal - Omega Computer Industries Pty Ltd and Garth Eric Walker - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T11296 of 2004 - Appeal dismissed - original Order confirmed

T11126 - 7 May 2004
President P.L. Leary, Commissioner T.J. Abey and Commissioner J.P. McAlpine
s70 appeal - Newemploy Pty Ltd and Australasian Meat Industry Employees' Union - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Shelley (as she then was) arising out of T10797 of 2003 - order issued

T11125 - 18 December 2006
President PL Leary, Commissioner TJ Abey and Commissioner JP McAlpine
s70 appeal - Blue Ribbon Products Pty Ltd and Australasian Meat Industry Employees' Union - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner P C Shelley arising out of T10797 of 2003 - Appeal upheld - Order revoked as far as it relates to Blue Ribbon Products Pty Ltd on the ground of supervening impossibility

T11109 - 16 January 2004
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Aquatas Pty Ltd and Gregory Riley - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T10796 of 2003 - appeal dismissed - Order varied

T11081 - 13 January 2004
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Patricia Monsour trading as Lochnagar Services and Jacqueline Oliver - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T10984 of 2003 - Appeal grounds 1(i),(ii),(iii), 2(i) and 3(i),(ii),(iii),(iv) upheld - Order revoked

T10893 - 22 March 2004
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Commissioner T.J. Abey and Commissioner J.P. McAlpine
s70 appeal - Barminco Pty Ltd and and The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Shelley arising out of T10668 of 2003 - Appeal grounds 3, 5 and 12 upheld - new Order issued

T10697 - 25 June 2003
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Kentish Council and Kevin Lewis Winduss - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T10298 of 2002 - Appeal grounds 3 and 4 upheld - new Order issued

T10662 and T10741 - 15 July 2003
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Tasman Group Services Pty Ltd
(T10662 of 2003) and Michael Hughes
Michael Hughes (T10741 of 2003) and Tasman Group Services Pty Ltd - appeals against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T10339 of 2002 - Appeals dismissed - decision confirmed

T10436 - 3 April 2003
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Adrian Bruce Sharam and Blue Tier Logging Pty Ltd - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T10228 of 2002 - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T10317 - 19 May 2003
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70 appeal - Northern Group Training Ltd and National Union of Workers, Tasmanian Branch - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Shelley arising out of T10001 of 2002 - Appeal Grounds 1, 2, 3 upheld, Ground 4 dismissed - whilst upholding 3 grounds of appeal the Bench have reached the same conclusion as Commissioner Shelley - original Order confirmed

T10313 and T10316 - 6 May 2003
s70 appeal - Commissioner of Police (T10313 of 2002) and Andrew Scott Gunston, Andrew Scott Gunston (T10316 of 2002) and Commissioner of Police - Directions

T10313 and T10316 - 13 February 2003
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Commissioner of Police (T10313 of 2002) and Andrew Scott Gunston
s70 appeal - Andrew Scott Gunston (T10316 of 2002) and Commissioner of Police - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of T9986 of 2002 - appeal dismissed in respect to findings that termination was unfair and no valid reason existed for the termination; matter of remedy subject to further hearing - Statement

T10313 and T10316 - 11 October 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70(1) appeals - Commissioner of Police (T10313 of 2002) and Andrew Scott Gunston (T10316 of 2002) - Directions

T10267 - 11 October 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s14 appeal - Long Service Leave Act 1976 - Netcraft Pty Ltd (T10267 of 2001) and Department of Infrastructure, Energy and Resources - Appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Imlach arising out of T9769 of 2001 - Appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T10126 - 15 August 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70(1) appeal - Brett Malcolm Youd
(T10126 of 2002) and Naracaa Pty Ltd - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner T J Abey arising out of matter T9943 of 2001 - Order varied

T10111 - 15 August 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70(1) appeal - Goldfields Limited and The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner P C Shelley arising out of matter T9601 of 2001 - alleged unfair termination of employment of Mr Barry Butler - appeal grounds 1, 5, 6 and 12 upheld - original Order revoked - new Order awarding compensation

T9968 - 15 February 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Imlach arising out of T9769 of 2001 - Netcraft Pty Ltd and Secretary, Department of Infrastructure, Energy and Resources, Workplace Standards, Tasmania re payment of pro rata long service leave - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T9833 - 15 May 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70 appeal against decision handed down by Commissioner P C Shelley arising out of T9163 of 2000 - Blue Ribbon Meat Products Pty Ltd and George Watson Carnie - Appeal Ground 7A upheld - original order revoked - new order issued

T9814 - 1 February 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70 appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner Imlach arising out of TE1130 of 2001 - G & A L Tambakis trading as Georgios Café and Takeaway and persons employed as Casual and Part-Time Employees - appeal upheld - decision revoked - new decision made - agreement approved pursuant to s61J of the Act

T9746 - 7 January 2002
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - lodged by the Launceston Community Legal Centre on behalf of Joshua John Strudwick against an order handed down by Commissioner Abey arising out of T9604 of 2001 - Joshua John Strudwick v Irish Murphy's Pty Ltd - jurisdiction of the Commission in respect to s30A of the Act - appeal dismissed - decision

T9620 - 18 September 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Commissioner P.A. Imlach, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70 appeal by Kenneth James Farrell against order handed down by Commissioner P C Shelley on 30 May 2001 in Matter T9288 of 2001 - Kenneth James Farrell v Crown in Right of State of Tasmania, Department of Premier and Cabinet - jurisdiction of Commission in respect of a former employee - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T9569 and T9577 - 25 September 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeals - Launceston Linen Service Pty Limited (T9569 of 2001) and Loraine May Hawksley (T9577 of 2001) - decision by Commissioner Abey on 8 May 2001 in matter T9428 of 2001 - appeals dismissed - decision confirmed

T9442 and T9443 - 26 September 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Commissioner P.A. Imlach, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70(1) appeal against an order - Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union and The Community and Public Sector Union, (State Public Services Federation Tasmania) AND The Community and Public Sector Union (State Public Services Federation Tasmania) and Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union - appeal against order handed down by Commissioner T J Abey on 16 February 2001 in Matter T9153 of 2000 - jurisdiction of Commission in respect of a former employee - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T9360 - 28 June 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (TCCI), on behalf of The People Source Ltd trading as North Western Group Training - decision by Abey C in Matter T9185 of 2000 - Paulina Martin v The People Source Ltd trading as North Western Group Training - Appeal Grounds 1, 2 and 3 dismissed - Appeal Ground 4 upheld - Order revoked - new Order issued

T9359 - 30 July 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70 appeal - A.C.N. 009 581 364 Pty Ltd (formerly Fee and Me Proprietary Limited A.C.N. 009 581 365) - decision by Commissioner PC Shelley in Matter T9209 of 2000 - Appeal upheld - Order revoked

T9287 - 18 September 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Commissioner P.A. Imlach, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70 appeal by Kenneth James Farrell (also known as Ken Farrell) against order handed down by Commissioner P C Shelley on 1 November 2001 in Matter T9147 of 2000 - Kenneth James Farrell (also known as Ken Farrell) v Crown in Right of State of Tasmania, through Office of the Leader of the Opposition - identification of employer - jurisdiction to enforce instrument of appointment - period of notice - hearsay evidence - procedural fairness - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T9149 - 15 February 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner T.J. Abey
s70(1) Notice of Appeal - Rosevears Estate Wines Pty Ltd (trading as Rosevears Estate) and Mathew James Alcorso -Directions

T9069 - 1 June 2001
Full Bench - President P.L. Leary, Deputy President R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry on behalf of its member Our Place Inc. against decision by Commissioner P C Shelley on 5 June 2000 in matter T8934 of 2000 - The Health Services Union of Australia, Tasmania No 1 Branch v Our Place Inc. - new evidence pursuant to s71(8) - public interest - unique and exceptional circumstances - order revoked - all grounds of appeal dismissed - T8934 of 2000 referred back to Commissioner P C Shelley to hear new evidence

T8874 - 5 April 2000
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Vanessa Kalamistrakis as Agent for an Employee Identified to the Commission - decision by President F D Westwood dated 14 February 2000 to approve an industrial agreement pursuant to Section 55 of the Industrial Relations Act 1984 in Matter T8787 of 2000 - The D W & C L Snare Launceston Airport Ground Handling Agreement 1999 - finding that at all material times there was no employer party to the agreement - finding that the Commission had no jurisdiction to deal with the agreement - appeal upheld - decision of the President revoked - file returned to Acting Registrar pursuant to Section 56(1A) of the Industrial Relations Act 1984 to revoke the registration of the agreement - Reasons for Further Decision and Correction Order

T8874 - 4 April 2000
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Vanessa Kalamistrakis as Agent for an Employee Identified to the Commission - decision by President F D Westwood dated 14 February 2000 to approve an industrial agreement pursuant to Section 55 of the Industrial Relations Act 1984 in Matter T8787 of 2000 - The D W & C L Snare Launceston Airport Ground Handling Agreement 1999 - finding that at all material times there was no employer party to the agreement - finding that the Commission had no jurisdiction to deal with the agreement - appeal upheld - decision of the President revoked - file returned to Acting Registrar pursuant to Section 56(1A) of the Industrial Relations Act 1984 to revoke the registration of the agreement

T8863 - 15 March 2000
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing & Kindred Industries Union - decision by Commissioner Imlach dated 16 February 2000 to refuse to approve an industrial agreement pursuant to Section 55 of the Industrial Relations Act 1984 in Matter T8785 of 2000 - Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing & Kindred Industries Union and Brambles Australia Ltd trading as Brambles Industrial Services - decision revoked - matter referred back to Commissioner Imlach to hear and determine

T8638 - 9 March 2000
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner P.L. Leary
s70 appeal - The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch against an order by Commissioner Imlach in matter T8441 of 1999 issued on 3 September 1999 - appeal dismissed - decision of Commissioner Imlach confirmed

T8595 - 11 November 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Wormald Australia Pty Ltd (now known as Tyco Australia Pty Ltd) against decision of Deputy President Johnson in T6668 of 1996, issued on 10 August 1999 - Security Industry Award - alleged breaches of nominated clauses in respect of 12-hour shift agreements - order issued directing employer to comply with terms and conditions of award - application withdrawn - matter dismissed

T8573 - 6 September 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing & Kindred Industries Union against an order by Commissioner Imlach in Matter T8548 of 1999 issued on 19 August 1999 - appeal withdrawn - file closed

T8529 - 1 September 1999
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Bill Tsakiris - against an order made by Deputy President King in Matter T8445 of 1999 - Bill Tsakiris v Denmar Pty Ltd (ACN 009 578 072), Petvic Pty Ltd (ACN 009 577 413), trading as Stokes & Hammond - appeal withdrawn - file closed

T8490 and T8491 - 21 December 1999
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.L. Leary
s70 appeals - Justin William Bartlett (T8490 of 1999) Rebecca Naomi Bishop (T8491 of 1999) and Nico Holdings Pty Ltd trading as McDonalds Invermay - decision by Imlach C in Matters T8096 and T8097 of 1999 issued on 16 June 1999 - appeals dismissed - decision of Commissioner Imlach confirmed

T8454 - 18 August 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Australian Mines and Metals Association (Incorporated) for Tasmanian Electro Metallurgical Company Pty Ltd - order made by Commissioner Imlach in matter T8373 of 1999 issued on 20 May 1999 - Paul John Rundle v Tasmanian Electro Metallurgical Company Pty Ltd - leave granted to a legal practitioner to appear - finding that Section 28 of the Industrial Relations Act 1984 does not place any constraint on who may sign an application for a hearing as agent - whether appeal grounds as lodged constituted an appeal for purposes of Section 70(1)(b) of the Act - finding that no appeal may be lodged until hearing concluded and an order made under Section 31(1) of the Act - appeal dismissed on grounds that it was not an appeal within the meaning of Section 70(1)(b) of the Act

T8452 - 17 December 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Andrew Paul Bryan McCullagh - order by Commissioner Imlach in Matter T8193 of 1999 issued on 20 May 1999 - Andrew Paul Bryan McCullagh v Evolution 2000 Real Estate Pty Ltd -alleged breach of Estate Agents Award - appeal dismissed - file closed

T8439 - 2 May 2000
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner P.L. Leary
s70 appeal - Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union, Tasmanian Branch - decision by Commissioner P A Imlach in matter T7772 of 1998 and T7773 of 1998 - Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union, Tasmanian Branch v RANS Management Group Pty Ltd trading as Tattersall's Hobart Aquatic Centre - breach of the Health and Fitness Centres Award - failure to pay over award payments not subject to breach of award provisions of the Act - breach of award calculated by reference to each pay period - Commissioner's reasons adequately canvassed in his decision - appeal grounds rejected - appeal dismissed - Commissioner's decision confirmed

T8415 - 29 June 2000
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.C. Shelley
s70 appeal - Gateway Tasmania Limited - decision and order of President F D Westwood dated 23 April 1999 to award severance pay - Gateway Tasmania Limited v Tricia Lette - decision and order of President in T7924 of 1998 confirmed - appeal dismissed

T8371 - 10 March 2000
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P. Leary
s70 appeal - appeal by Roadways Pty Ltd ACN 009 485 812 - decision by Deputy President Johnson on 23 March 1999 in matter T7212 of 1997 - Terrence James Price v Roadways Pty Ltd ACN 009 485 812 - re termination of employment of Terrence James Price - appeal dismissed - order confirmed

T8234 - 2 July 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President J.G. King, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union - Tasmanian Branch - against orders by Deputy President Johnson in Matters T7515 of 1998 and T7516 of 1998 issued 12 January 1999 - re termination of employment of David Mitchell and Peter Jones by P & O Services Pty Ltd - Article 12 of the ILO Convention - held that Deputy President should have taken into account Article 12 in respect of David Mitchell - appeal upheld in part - appeal dismissed in respect of Peter Jones - order in respect of David Mitchell varied - order in respect of Peter Jones confirmed

T8170 and T8171 - 3 November 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P. Leary
s70 appeals - Geoffrey Gerald Corrigan (T8170 of 1998) and Kelair Pumps Australia Pty Ltd ACN 001 308 381 (T8171 of 1998) - decision by Deputy President King on 3 December 1998 in matter T7771 of 1998 - termination of employment resulting from redundancy - severance pay not compensation - decision and order revoked - original application referred to another member to hear and determine the question of severance pay in accordance with directions of the Full Bench

T8103 - 5 February 1999
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Maree Maina-Stocks - decision by President F D Westwood on 5 November 1998 in matter T7643 of 1998 - Maree Maina-Stocks v Jane and Robert de Little trading as Mount Lord Apricots - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T8081 - 11 June 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Albertus Letter - decision by Commissioner P A Imlach on 29 October 1998 in matter T7897 of 1998 - Albertus Letter v Pioneer Building Products Pty Ltd - no time limit for lodging applications made pursuant to s29(1A)(b) - appeal upheld - order revoked - application T7897 referred to Deputy President Johnson for hearing and determination

T8047 - 28 July 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal by Rick Andrew Allie against an order handed down by Deputy President J G King on 12 October 1998 in Matter T7941 of 1998 - Rick Andrew Allie v Island Block and Paving Pty Ltd - decision revoked - reinstatement impractical - order issued

T8040 - 30 March 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited for and on behalf of ACN 009 581 364 Pty Limited (formerly known as Fee and Me Pty Limited) - decision by Commissioner Imlach on 5 October 1998 in Matter T7802 of 1998 re alleged breach of the Restaurant Keepers Award - applicant in the matter at first instance lacked power to make application - by consent of parties appeal upheld - decision and order revoked

T8004 and T8013 - 31 May 1999
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeals - Betta Milk Co-op Society Limited trading as Betta Milk (T8013 of 1998) and Philip Tony Patterson (T8004 of 1998) - against an order handed down by President F D Westwood on 10 September 1998 in matter T6945 of 1997 - Philip Tony Patterson v Betta Milk Co-op. trading as Betta Milk - appeals dismissed - decision and order confirmed

T7998 - 5 August 1999
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner P. Leary
s70 appeal - Andrew Martin Pearson - decision and order by Commissioner Watling on 9 September 1998 in Matter T6983 of 1997 - Andrew Martin Pearson v Gunns Limited, trading as Gunns Mitre 10 - re termination of employment - appeal dismissed - order confirmed

T7666 - 1 April 1999
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - The Community and Public Sector Union (State Public Services Federation Tasmania) against a decision by President F D Westwood on 17 April 1998 in matter T7589 of 1998 - application dismissed - file closed

T7666 - 19 June 1998
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - The Community and Public Sector Union (State Public Services Federation Tasmania) against a decision by President F D Westwood on 17 April 1998 in matter T7589 of 1998 - matter referred back to the President for clarification - Interim Decision

T7585 - 24 August 1998
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited- Restaurant Keepers Award - decision by President F D Westwood on 17 February 1998 in matter T6540 of 1996 - appeal dismissed - declaration varied

T7402 - 11 September 1998
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Deputy President J.G. King (Dissenting)
s70 appeal - appeal by Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited for and on behalf of Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City against a decision by Commissioner R J Watling on 19 November 1997 in matter T7008 of 1997 - Timothy Richard Smith v Classic Video Pty Ltd trading as Video City - decision and order confirmed - appeal dismissed

T7387 - 3 June 1998
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach (Dissenting)
s70 appeal - appeal by Mark Meaney against order handed down by Deputy President King on 24.11.97 in matter T7125 of 1997 in relation to the termination of Mr Meaney's employment with Sacred Heart College - Appeal dismissed by majority decision - order of Deputy President confirmed

T7168 - 9 July 1998
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - appeal by Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited for and on behalf of Fosseys (Australia) Pty Ltd against a decision by President F D Westwood on 18 July 1997 in matters T6674, T6675, T6676 of 1996 and T6691, T6692, T6693, T6694, T6695, T6696 and T6704 of 1997 - Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union - Tasmanian Branch and Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees Association, Tasmanian Branch v Fosseys (Australia) Pty Ltd - redundancy payments - decision confirmed - appeal dismissed

T6915 and T6918 - 1 October 1997
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Capital Hill Corporation Pty Ltd
(ACN 066 774 285) (T6915 of 1997) and Terence James O'Connor (T6918 of 1997) - appeals - decision by President F D Westwood on 27 March 1997 in matter T6563 of 1996 - appeals dismissed - decision confirmed

T6795 - 14 April, 1997
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Deputy President J.G. King, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - appeal by Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union Tasmanian Branch against a declaration by President Westwood on 6 February 1997 in matter T6540 of 1996 - Clause 9 - Annual Leave, Restaurant Keepers Award - declaration revoked - matter T6540 referred back to President Westwood

T6701 - 30 June 1997
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - appeal by Raymond John Hanson against a decision by Commissioner P A Imlach on 19 December 1996 in matter T6528 of 1996 - Raymond John Hanson v Cosgrove Park Bowls Club Inc - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T6678 - 1 July 1997
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - appeal by Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited on behalf of Gloria Marshall Figure Salon against a decision and order issued on 6 December by Commissioner Imlach in Application T6496 of 1996 - termination of employment of certain employees of Gloria Marshall Figure Salon - order made by Commissioner revoked - matter referred back to Commissioner for further action

T6658 - 4 July, 1997
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - appeal by Trevor William Monson - decision by Commissioner R J Watling on 21 November 1996 in matter T6592 of 1996 - The Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union, Tasmanian Branch v Blue Ribbon Meat Products Pty Ltd - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T6639 - 28 February 1997
Full Bench - Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - The Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union,Tasmanian Branch - declaration by President Westwood on 12 November 1996 in matter T6257 of 1996 - Abattoirs Award - meaning of proviso re apprentices wage rates - appeal dismissed - declaration confirmed

T6469 - 10 October 1996
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - The Community and Public Sector Union (State Public Services Federation Tasmania) - decision handed down by Commissioner R J Watling on 8 July 1996 in matter T6226 of 1996 - alleged award breaches - appeal dismissed - decision confirmed

T6468 - 5 December 1996
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - The Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch - against order handed down by Commissioner Imlach on 6 August 1996 in Matter T6247 of 1996 in relation to termination of an employee of Pasminco Metals-EZ

T6449 - 10 October 1996
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited for and on behalf of Thermoform Packaging Pty Ltd - against order issued on 25.7.96 by Commissioner Imlach in Matter T5795 of 1995 - appeal upheld - order revoked - Commissioner directed to convene further hearing to establish award entitlements, if any

T6371 - 13 August 1996
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President B.R. Johnson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited - appeal against order handed down by Commissioner Imlach on 26 June 1996 in Matter T6038 of 1996 re redundancy payments for former employees at Chubb Australia Limited - no jurisdiction

T6181 - 5 June 1996
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Hazell Pty Ltd (now Trident Consolidated Industries) - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner P A Imlach on 1 April 1996 in matter T6029 of 1996 - Long Service Leave - pro rata entitlement - appeal upheld

T6041 - 5 February 1996
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70(1) appeal - Minister for Public Sector Management - appeal against order to reinstate a dismissed employee handed down by Deputy President Robinson on 21.12.95 in Matter T5994 of 1995 - appeal dismissed - order confirmed

T5480 - 22 September 1995
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - AWU-FIME Amalgamated Union, Tasmania Branch - Roadmakers Award - appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner R K Gozzi on 11 April 1995 in matter T4190 of 1992 - Roadmakers Award

T5452 - 13 July 1995
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal against a decision handed down by Commissioner R K Gozzi on 24 March 1995 in matters T2225 of 1989, T2311 of 1990 and T4146 of 1992 - Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union - Community Services Award

T5258 - 15 November 1994
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal against a decision handed down by President Westwood on 7 October 1994 in matter T5104 of 1994 - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited - Mr A. Purves trading as Purves Fisheries and Mr Crawford - long service leave

T4826, T4591, T4820 and 4827 - 11 August 1994
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeals - Minister administering the Tasmanian State Service Act 1984 being the Minister for Public Sector Management (T4826 of 1994) and Australian Education Union, Tasmanian Branch (T Nos 4591 of 1993 and 4820 and 4827 of 1994) - against order in matters T2417, T3611, T3709, T4074, T2113, T3690 and T4077 - Technical and Further Education Staff Award

T4790 - 27 April 1994
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Pasminco Metals E.Z.- against an order handed down by Commissioner R. K. Gozzi on 24 December 1993 in matters T4639 of 1993, and T Nos 4750, 4751, 4752, 4753, 4754, 4755, 4756, 4757, 4758, 4759, 4760, 4761, 4762 and 4763 of 1993

T4774 - 30 May 1994
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70(1) appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited - appeal against an order handed down by Deputy President Robinson on 26 November 1993 in matter T4333 of 1993 - jurisdiction - power to award a sum of money - legal representation - order revoked

T4715 of 1993 - 22 December 1993
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Limited - Appeal - interpretation - Declaration and Order in T.Nos. 4614, 4615, 4616, 4617, 4619, 4620 and 4621 of 1993 - Musicians Award - appeal upheld - Declaration and Order revoked

T4579 of 1993 - 10 December 1993
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal against decision in matter T4431 of 1993 - Teaching Service (Teaching Staff) Award - District allowances - operative date - appeal upheld - Order quashed - new Order - operative date of ffpp 6 July 1993

T4110, T4111 and T4112 - 19 February 1992
Full Bench - Deputy President Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - The Ambulance Employees' Association of Tasmania against decision in matters T.2586 and T.3779 of 1992 - Tasmanian Ambulance Service Award - Clause 23(b) - a provision that 28 days notice of roster change need not be given in certain circumstances - Clause 23(f) - stand down between 2400 and 0700 hours - inclusion of new classification of Ambulance Technician - appeals dismissed

T4086 and T4080 - 24 May 1994
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeals - Electrical, Electronic, Plumbing and Allied Workers Union of Australia (T4086 of 1992) and Automotive, Food, Metals and Engineering Union (T4080 of 1992) - against an order handed down by Commissioner Gozzi on 2 November 1992 in matter T3909 of 1992 - Ferro Alloys Award

T4064 of 1992 - 23 February 1993
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal by Tasmanian Confederation of Industries against decision in matter T3875 of 1992 - Automotive Industries Award - scope clause - appeal dismissed

T4012 and T4023 of 1992 - 17 December 1992
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Metals and Engineering Workers' Union
(T.4012 of 1992) and Electrical Trades Union of Australia, Tasmanian Branch (T.4023 of 1992) - Ferro Alloys Award - appeals against decision in matter T3909 of 1992 - variation of the Ferro Alloys Award - appeals dismissed

T4000 of 1992 - 11 November 1992
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Metals and Engineering Workers' Union - Metal and Engineering Industry Award - appeal against decision of Commissioner in matter T3870

T3971 of 1992 - 3 November 1992
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Roger John and Robin Dianne Stanley
(trading as the Empire Hotel) - appeal against decision in matter T3851 of 1992 - long service leave - appeal dismissed

T3755 of 1992 - 2 July 1992
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Federated Miscellaneous Workers Union of Australia - Independent Schools (Non-Teaching Staff) Award -appeal against decision of Commissioner Imlach on 1 October 1991 in T2971 of 1991

T3578 of 1991 - 18 May 1992
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Federation of Industrial, Manufacturing and Engineering Employees, Tasmania Branch - Tasmanian Government Departments (Mechanical and Electrical) Engineering Award - T3036 of 1991 - award interest determination

T3177 of 1991 - 10 December 1991
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries - Miscellaneous Workers Award - appeal against T2820 of 1990 of Commissioner Imlach

T3177 of 1991 - 7 October 1991
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries - Miscellaneous Workers Award - appeal against decision of Commissioner - T2820 of 1990 - Interim Decision

T3174 - 10 December 1991
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries - Miscellaneous Workers Award - appeal against T2820 of 1990 of Commissioner Imlach

T3094 of 1991 - 2 October 1991
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal against a declaration by the President - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries - Hairdressers Award - interpretation declaration (T2495 and T2686) made pursuant to Section 43 of the Act

T3025 and T2956 of 1991 - 31 May 1991
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Transport Workers' Union of Australia, Tasmanian Branch (T3025 of 1991) and Pasminco Mining (Rosebery) (T2956 of 1991) - Pasminco Mining (Rosebery) Award - appeal against T2956 of 1991 by Commissioner Gozzi to include a provision in an award relating to wage rates applicable to the classifications of Mill Operator and Surface Operator by an amount of $21.10 per week retrospectively

T2877 of 1991 - 13 March 1991
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissisoner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries - Transport Workers General Award - appeal against decision in matter T2334 of 1990 - Refusal to insert a Majority Clause - appeal upheld

T2603 of 1990 - 14 January 1991
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissisoner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Minister Administering the Tasmanian State Service Act 1984 - Miscellaneous Workers (Public Sector) Award - appeal against decision in matter T1526 of 1988 - Appeal Upheld - Directions Issued

T2356, T2357, T2358 of 1990 - 12 August 1994
Full Bench - President F.D. Westwood, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70(1) appeals against orders - Tasmanian Public Service Association (now the State Public Services Federation Tasmania) - Keyboard Employees and Office Assistants Award (T2356 of 1990), Hospital Scientists Award (T2357 of 1990), Welfare Workers Award (T2358 of 1990) - appeals against determinations by Commissioner Imlach in Matters TP1/9, TP1/8 and TP1/16, re award interest of the Hospital Employees Federation of Australia, Tasmania Branch (now the Health Services Union of Australia Tasmania No. 1 Branch) in the Keyboard and Office Assistants Award, the Hospital Scientists Award and the Welfare Workers Award respectively - appeals withdrawn

T2280 - 16 March 1990
Full Bench - Acting President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commission P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - National Union of Storeworkers, Packers, Rubber and Allied Workers against decision T2239 - Leather, Canvas and Sheet Plastic Fabrication

T2148 of 1989 - 6 December 1989
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s14 appeal - Mr W.R. Butler against decision in matter T2077 of 1989 - pro rata long service leave

T2111 - 13 November 1989
Full Bench - Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s70 appeal - Transport Workers' Union of Australia, Tasmanian Branch against decision T1952, T1953, T1984 and T1990 of 1989 - Chemists Award - 3% superannuation

T2109 - 1 November 1989
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner P.A. Imlach
s14 appeal - Kingborough Nursing Home Pty Ltd against decision in matter T1840 of 1989 - pro rata long service leave

T1985 of 1989 - 26 July 1989
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries against a decision of the President in T1837 of 1989 - Bakers Award - payment for period of leave

T1946 - 11 August 1989
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Messrs James Forrester McAra and John Wallace against a decision by Commissioner Gozzi in matter T1764 of 1988 - long service leave dispute between Mr J. McAra and Mr J. Wallace, and Coats Patons Handknittings

T1929 - 19 December 1989
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries against a declaration made under section 43 of the Act by President L.A. Koerbin in matter T1824 of 1989 - Retail Trades Award

T1832 - 25 July 1989
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Hospital Employees Federation of Australia, Tasmania Branch against a decision of Commissioner King in matter T1654 of 1988 - Hospitals Award

T1724 of 1988 - 19 January 1989
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner J.G. King, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries against part of a decision of Commissioner Watling in TA41 and T1222 of 1988

T1521 and T1522 of 1988 - 20 October 1988
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Public Service Association and the Hospital Employees Federation of Australia, Tasmania No. 2 Branch respectively against a decision of Commissioner King in T1301, TA35 and T1425 of 1988 - Hospital Employees (Public Hospitals) Award - salary rates and classification structure for radiographers

T1429 of 1988 - 19 October 1988
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner J.G. King
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries against a decision of Commissioner Watling in matter T1117 of 1988 - Sea Based Fin Fish Farm employees

T1421 of 1988 - 19 December 1988
Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Public Service Association against decision in Matter TA34 of 1988 - Inland Fisheries Commission Staff Award

T1379 of 1988 - 5 September 1988
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Australian Workers' Union, Tasmania Branch against a decision by Commissioner King in matter T1099 of 1987 - Cement Makers Award

T1360 and T1377 - 19 September 1988
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Hospital Employees Federation of Australia, Tasmania No. 2 and Tasmania No. 1 Branches respectively against a decision of Commissioner King in matters T721 and T999 of 1987 - Hospitals Award, Divisions A, C and D

T1360 and T1377 - 19 September 1988
Full Bench Direction to Commissioner King

T1318 of 1988 - 21 June 1988
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Commissioner J.G. King, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Minister for Public Administrtion against a decision of the Deputy President in matter T1060 of 1987 - Fire Brigades Award - second tier increase - referred back to Deputy President

T1005 - 29 February 1988
Full Bench -Deputy President, Commissioner J.G. King, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries - Miscellaneous Workers Award - insertion of new clause pertaining to video hire establishments - appeal against decision of Commissioner Watling in matter T862 of 1987

T971 of 1987 - 24 March 1988
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Minister for Public Administration against a decision by Commissioner Gozzi in matter T299 of 1985 - Mainland Allowance

T845 of 1987 - 7 August 1987
Full Bench - Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner J.G. King, Commissioner R. K. Gozzi
s14 appeal - Mr L.N. Behrens against T747 of 1987 - long service leave dispute between Mr L.N. Behrens and the Tasmanian Government Insurance Office - payment of pro rata Long Service Leave

T799 of 1987 - 8 July 1987
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner J.G. King, Commissioner R. K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Public Service Association against a decision by Commissioner Watling in matter T701 of 1987 - Librarians Award

T793 of 1987 - 17 July 1987
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Commissioner R. K. Gozzi, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s14 appeal - Savage River Mines against a decision of Commissioner King in matter T629 of 1986 (Long Service Leave dispute between Mr N.T. Carey and Savage River Mines) - entitlement to payment for accrued Long Service Leave

T758 of 1987 - 30 July 1987
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s14 appeal - Mr R.H. Gorman against a decision by Commissioner King in matter T618 of 1986 - long service leave dispute

T754 of 1987 - 1 October 1987
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner J.G. King
s14 appeal - Tasmanian Confederation of Industries against decision T657 of 1987 - long service leave dispute

T690 - 12 March 1987
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Commissioner Gozzi, Commissioner Watling
s14 appeal - Mr B.O. O'Conor against a decision by Commissioner King in matter T544 of 1986 (Long Service Leave dispute between Mr T.B. Weir and O'Conors Shoe Store) - long service leave entitlement - appeal disallowed

T632 - 2 April 1987
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Commissioner R.J. Watling, Commissioner R.K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Industries against a decision by Deputy President in matter T558 of 1986 - Marine Boards Award - Service and Experience Payments - appeal dismissed

T444 of 1986 - 19 November 1986
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Commissioner J.G. King, Commissioner R. K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Farmers' and Graziers' Employers' Association against the decision in matter T353 of 1986 - re shearing of goats

T429 of 1986 - 14 October 1986
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Commissioner R. K. Gozzi, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s14 appeal - W.J. James against matter T369 of 1986 - long service leave dispute

T366 - 27 May 1986
Full Bench - President Koerbin, Deputy President Robinson, Commissioner King
s14 appeal - Tasmanian Chamber of Industries on behalf of Derwent Court Nursing Home against determination of Commissioner Watling in T308 of 1986 regarding a disputed long service leave claim

T360 of 1986 - 11 April, 1986
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner R.J. Watling
s70 appeal - Tasmanian Teachers Federation against a decision of the commission (T316 of 1986) in relation to the Teaching Service (Teaching Staff) Award - savings provision for Mr W. Tomalin

T331 of 1986 - 10 April 1986
Full Bench - Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner J.G. King, Commissioner R. K. Gozzi
s70 appeal - Federated Engine Drivers' and Firemen's Association of Australasia (Tasmanian Branch) against the decision in matter T282 of 1985 - insertion of classification Boiler Attendant in the Vegetable Preservers Award

T194 and T196 of 1985 - 22 May 1986
Full Bench - President L.A. Koerbin, Deputy President A. Robinson, Commissioner J.G. King
s70 appeals - Australian Social Welfare Union and the Federated Miscellaneous Workers' Union respectively - appeals against a decision of Commissioner Gozzi in Matters T19 and T20 of 1985 regarding the making of the Community Services Award